Competition Results > 2026 Platinum Reviews - Spirits

Director Rich Cook's reviews of our Platinum Award winners are posting here - check back often!

Weldon Mills Bourbon Barrel Gin, Batch No: 6 ($45)
I often advise Gin fnas that barrel rested Gin might not be their thing, particularly if they have a strong preference for the clear side of the spirits spectrum. That said, this bottling might not just be a delicious find, it might just be the bottle that cracks open the door to the world of brown spirits for Gin enthusiasts. The barrel aromatics are out front here, with vanilla and caramel nots riding atop the expected juniper and botanical elements that make a Gin what it is. On the palate, though, the vanilla and caramel notes fade into the background, letting the bright juniper character prized by fans take center stage. It's a fine spiier on its own, or try it as the Gin portion of a Negroni or the Rye portion of an Old Fashioned. Unique! 96

Noble Coyote Mezcal Artesanal Maguey Espadín Joven ($60)
This is a beautiful Mezcal - remarkable for its purity of character and fine tuned smokiness. The nose shows rich Espadín notes of mellow lime, anise, grass and soft pepper, with just enough smoke to let you know what it is. The "Artesanal" designation means that this bottle was made by hand with no diffuser or autoclave, and that's on full display here. The palate brings the smoke a little more forward, joining the promised mix of flavors. There's no sweetness here, just purity, balance and great finish length. With the current demand for high quality mezcal, this bottle offers real value for your dollar. Well done! Handled in the USA by the Agave Trader. 96

Uncle Nearest 1856 Premium Aged Whiskey ($45)
Here’s a straightforward American whiskey that is like pulling on a warm blanket. Aromas of nut and toasted marshmallow entice, and the palate delivers the promised flavors with brightness and lightness. There’s no lingering viscosity to interfere with the flavors – just plenty of warmth and sweet character that really last. Sip neat, on a large clear rock, or use in your favorite cocktails. I’m getting visions of campfire recipes…  95

Noble Coyote Mezcal Jabalí Joven ($120)
Jabalí agave is a wild, difficult to cultivate and slow to mature agave, and it presents a unique profile in the glass. This particular expression is extremely aromatic, showing preserved lemon/lime, wet stone and drying grass notes. The palate is quite mellow and complex, with Mezcal's signature smoky character showing as a subtle accent rather than a dominant aspect. It's a sublime sipper that will deepen your appreciation for what is possible in the world of Oaxacan agave distillates. Sold in 700ml bottles, and handled in the USA by the Agave Trader. 95

Weldon Mills Reserve Straight Bourbon Whiskey, Barrel Proof, Batch No: 1 ($65)
Whether it's sommeliers, critics, distillers or composite panels of judges, this product always seems to make it to my review desk at competitions. Whatever the batch number, it delivers consistent quality and character batch after batch. I'm always ready to taste a bourbon that delivers deep caramelized aromas and finely balanced spirit notes that come across without any syrupy sweetness or cloying charaacter on the palate. I wonder if the distillery does a side by side tasting of the different batches of this reserve offering - if not, they're missing an opportunity to really show off what they're dedicated to. Bravo! 94

Uncle Nearest Single Barrel Premium Whiskey, Barrel No. 862 ($90)
Now that's a spicy meatball! Or in this case, a beautifully spiced whiskey. And coming in a just over fifity eight and a half percent ABV, there's more kick than just the spice profile from Barrel 862, which pops with Saigon cinnamon brightness from start to finish. The heat is well folded without being washed out by the spice, corn and grain - you're not buying barrel strength for subtlety, after all, but the best examples in this category deliver finely tuned balance, and this one certainly does so. Go neat if you dare, or pour over a big clear cube to release a mellow complexity. 95

 

Weldon Mills Norman's 53 Single Barrel Straight Bourbon Whiskey, Barrel 3 ($295)
Here's a stunning Bourbon that comes in a package that's a perfect splurge gift for the boss or a fellow aficionado. Of course it might just become a centerpiece in your liquor cabinet. All of that is nice, but it's really of no consequence if it doesn't deliver in the glass upon leaving the package and showing itself. This is the third barrel edition that I've had the pleasure to taste, and it's amazingly refined for a barrel proof offering. No one element shouts for attention as the corn, grain and barrel spice influence intertwine elegantly and linger well into the distance with none of the ey popping burn that you often see at 60% ABV and above level. My favorite release of Norman's 53 to date, and I'm excited to taste the next one. Bravo! 98

 

 


  << Return